Polariod Border
Polariod Border
ClimateX
University of Oxford Logo
Scrabook Top Border
Log In

Confusion

laurien on 3rd May 07, 15:09:53 said:

I think it's all amazingly positive, and it's great what's being done in Wolvercote, but I'm now more confused than ever. (1) Should I shop locally even though goods might not have been sourced locally? Should I buy local produce even though it might have been produced out of season whereas stuff from abroad might be in season? What about fair trade for Africa? (2) Should I have solar panels even though they take 15 years(?) to pay back the energy taken to manufacture them? Anyway, would I be allowed them on my south-facing roof, which faces the street in a conservation area? Similar question re double glazing. (3) Apparently energy from Good Energy would cost me £75/year more than what I have now; travelling by train abroad would cost miles more than by plane (OK, (3) is just an excuse I know - don't go - forget this item).

pendlenton on 4th May 07, 15:37:03 replied:

Dear Laurien Just wanted to say- think there is no right answer- the process itself may be the solution. As long as you're trying, you can't go wrong. Often felt overwhelmed myself, but am just trying to do what I can and not worry about what I can't! Hope this encourages you in some way, at least if you know that confusion is common! all the best


gobion on 9th May 07, 11:55:13 replied:

(1) Should I shop locally even though goods might not have been sourced locally? Should I buy local produce even though it might have been produced out of season whereas stuff from abroad might be in season? What about fair trade for Africa?

That is a tough question - and one we are currently making a game about! It is hard for people to balance all these conflicting requirements.  For me personally, I tend to shop Fair Trade for goods which are not grown locally (and which it would not make sense to grow locally) such as coffee, chocolate, tea, bananas etc.

For everything else I try to shop locally first and then organic second as the supermarkets have a tendency to charge 100% more for organic produce.

Eating seasonally is great and I try whenever we can. Trueth be told we are having a go at attempting our first herb garden at the moment. Its good fun for me (I'm a complete novice!) 

(2) Should I have solar panels even though they take 15 years(?) to pay back the energy taken to manufacture them? Anyway, would I be allowed them on my south-facing roof, which faces the street in a conservation area?

This is a very tricky one but one with light at the end of the tunnel. Ian posted a link to a really interesting story on this issue: http://climatex.org/forums/lower-carbon-societies/26/ 

Similar question re double glazing. (3) Apparently energy from Good Energy would cost me £75/year more than what I have now;

Yeah a toughie - we have opted to use Good Energy, but when you are on a budget it can be a tough call. Other providers do provide renreables though, so it is worth shopping around (I believe uSwitch.com allows you to compare green energy providers). 

travelling by train abroad would cost miles more than by plane

But you are should travel. There are a new generation of far cleaner planes coming in, but frankly I think it comes down to senseible balancing. Do you need to go by plane? Is the trip important?

Hannah, my wife, and I are planning a trip to Spain, and we are looking at catching various trains there (via Paris and Bacelona) and stopping off along the way. We will probably fly back though!

Anyway, just some thoughts!

Cheers,

Gobion 


alvinwriter on 10th Sep 07, 11:35:27 replied:

We cannot escape the conveniences of the modern world without sacrificing something. The same goes for going green. There will be consequences one way or the other. Yet we do have to make choices and the best that we can do is to make the ones that will minimize our carbon (dioxide) footprint enough to contribute to mitigating the release of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. We should be conscious of the things we do everyday in order to make the correct decisions. 'The Greenhouse Effect and Your Country's Contribution to It': http://www.thenewsroom.com/details/169645?c_id=wom-bc-ar - Alvin from TheScienceDesk at TheNewsRoom.com